Scene It Before? Aamir Khan Defends Remakes as 'Sitaare Zameen Par' Faces Copy-Paste Critique

As excitement builds for his upcoming film Sitaare Zameen Par, Aamir Khan has found himself at the heart of a spirited discussion about Bollywood’s remake culture. In a recent press interaction, Aamir stood up for his decision to adapt stories for Indian audiences, highlighting that remakes can be a meaningful way to share impactful narratives with a broader audience.

 

“Remakes aren’t just about copying—they’re about reinterpreting a story within a new cultural framework,” Aamir shared. “If a story has the ability to touch people, why not present it to more viewers in a language and setting they can relate to?” He pointed to the success of Ghajini and Laal Singh Chaddha—both adaptations—as proof that remakes can truly resonate when approached thoughtfully.

 

However, reactions online have been mixed. While some fans applauded Aamir’s candidness and his history of creating meaningful cinema, others expressed concerns about originality. A viral comment captured the skepticism perfectly: “Toh kya frame to frame copy karoge?”—a sharp question about whether Sitaare Zameen Par will bring a fresh perspective or merely mimic its original source.

 

Aamir reassured fans that his goal is always to infuse value and authenticity, promising that Sitaare Zameen Par will include new elements and a distinct emotional core. As the film’s release approaches, the debate around remakes continues, with Aamir Khan’s creative decisions once again taking center stage.

 

Source: Hindustan Times