Curtains Up on Caution: Why the National Film Awards Must Guard Their Own Script

The 71st National Film Awards, announced in August 2025, have triggered intense controversies, revealing systemic issues around jury decisions, political influences, and credibility challenges. Once regarded as the gold standard recognizing cinematic excellence across India’s diversity, the awards now face criticism that threatens their sanctity from within, making protection and reform imperative.

 

Key Highlights: Controversial Decisions Stir Public Outcry

 

The awards faced backlash over the notable snubbing of critically acclaimed Malayalam film Aadujeevitham (The Goat Life), with prominent actors and filmmakers accusing the jury of political bias and ignoring true merit. Legendary actress Urvashi, herself a winner, criticized the sidelining of Aadujeevitham and questioned the jury’s integrity, alleging politics tainted selections.

 

The awarding of Best Director and Best Cinematography to The Kerala Story ignited fierce debates. Kerala’s Chief Minister and opposition leaders condemned the decision as a "grave insult" to Kerala, accusing the film of promoting misinformation and divisive ideologies. Several jury members dissented publicly, labeling the film as propagandist rather than artistic.

 

Urvashi also highlighted procedural irregularities, such as lead actors (including herself and actor Vijayaraghavan) being relegated to the "Supporting Actor" category, which undermines proper recognition and disrespects artists’ contributions.

 

The selection of Shah Rukh Khan for Best Actor faced skepticism and allegations of unclear criteria from peers, further fueling doubts about transparency and fairness in the jury’s evaluation methods.

 

Systemic Issues Exposed: Jury Transparency and Political Influence

 

The jury’s decisions appear affected by external political pressures and internal inconsistencies. Statements and leaked comments reveal politics impacting who is honored, favoring films aligned with certain ideological narratives while ignoring diverse or critical voices.

 

The lack of clarity on criteria for categories and sudden changes compared to historical precedents—like not sharing the Best Actress award despite multiple strong performances—disrupts traditional trust in the process.

 

The absence of clear communication about jury deliberations intensifies suspicions. Recipients like Urvashi express their discomfort openly, a rare break from the usual acceptance, reflecting widespread industry frustration.

 

Critics worry that the National Film Awards risk becoming a platform for political signaling rather than excellence recognition, diminishing their status both nationally and globally.

 

Why Protection and Reform Are Essential

 

The National Film Awards symbolize the cultural diversity, artistic innovation, and social reflection through India’s cinematic landscape. Compromising on integrity threatens not only individual careers but the collective morale of the filmmaking community.

 

Ongoing controversies erode public trust, leading to disillusionment among filmmakers and audiences who rely on these awards for credible acknowledgment.

 

Protecting the awards entails instituting transparent, standardized criteria, safeguarding jury independence, and distancing creative recognition from partisan influences.

 

Greater engagement with stakeholders—filmmakers, critics, cultural bodies—and clearer communication strategies can restore faith and uphold the awards’ historic prestige.

 

Calls for Accountability and Future Outlook

 

Industry veterans, critics, and activists are urging the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting, along with the National Film Development Corporation and jury panels, to implement reforms ensuring robust impartiality.

 

Emphasizing artistic merit and fostering inclusivity across regional cinemas would counteract perceptions of bias against south Indian films or specific genres.

 

Ongoing debates and public discourse could catalyze broader improvements in Indian cinema’s institutional frameworks, setting higher standards for cultural honors.

 

In conclusion, the fallout around the 71st National Film Awards reveals deep-seated challenges threatening this prestigious institution from within. Protecting the awards demands vigilant reforms that prioritize artistic integrity, transparent processes, and political neutrality, securing their role as a beacon of Indian cinema’s finest achievements.

 

Sources: Indian Express, Wikipedia, Times of India