Image Source : HT Auto
For Indian families seeking a spacious, feature-rich, and budget-friendly multi-purpose vehicle (MPV), the Maruti Ertiga and Kia Carens Clavis emerge as two compelling contenders. With a price ceiling of ₹15 lakh, buyers are often torn between the Ertiga’s proven reliability and the Carens Clavis’s premium appeal. This newsletter offers a comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision.
Key Highlights at a Glance
- Maruti Ertiga offers better fuel efficiency and lower ownership costs
- Kia Carens Clavis delivers more premium features and cabin sophistication
- Ertiga’s automatic variant fits comfortably under ₹15 lakh
- Carens Clavis turbo-auto variant exceeds the budget cap
Price and Variants
The Maruti Ertiga starts at ₹8.96 lakh (ex-showroom) and tops out around ₹13.26 lakh for the ZXI Plus AT variant. It offers both manual and automatic options, including a CNG variant for added efficiency.
The Kia Carens Clavis begins at ₹11.50 lakh (ex-showroom) for the HTE 1.5 Petrol MT. However, its turbocharged automatic variants are priced well above ₹15 lakh, making them inaccessible for budget-conscious buyers.
Engine and Performance
Maruti Ertiga
- Engine: 1462 cc K15C Smart Hybrid petrol
- Power: 101.64 bhp
- Torque: 139 Nm
- Transmission: 6-speed automatic
- Mileage: 20.3 kmpl (ARAI)
Kia Carens Clavis
- Engine: 1497 cc Smartstream G1.5 petrol
- Power: 113 bhp
- Torque: 144 Nm
- Transmission: 6-speed manual or 7-speed DCT (turbo variant)
- Mileage: 16.66 kmpl (ARAI)
While the Carens Clavis offers slightly more power, the Ertiga’s hybrid system and fuel efficiency give it a clear edge in daily usability and running costs.
Space and Comfort
Both MPVs offer three-row seating, but differ in layout and feel:
- Ertiga seats seven passengers and has a more utilitarian cabin
- Carens Clavis seats six or seven depending on the variant, with a more premium interior finish
The Carens Clavis boasts a longer wheelbase (2780 mm vs Ertiga’s 2740 mm), translating to better legroom in the second and third rows. However, Ertiga’s cabin is more practical, with ample storage and a flat-folding third row.
Features and Technology
Kia Carens Clavis
- 10.25-inch touchscreen infotainment system
- Six airbags standard
- Rear disc brakes
- Premium upholstery and ambient lighting
- Roof-mounted AC vents for all rows
Maruti Ertiga
- 7-inch SmartPlay infotainment system
- Dual airbags standard
- Rear parking sensors
- Suzuki Connect telematics
- Air-cooled cup holders and smartphone storage
The Carens Clavis clearly wins on features, offering a more upmarket experience. However, many of these are reserved for higher variants that exceed the ₹15 lakh threshold.
Safety Ratings
Both MPVs received three-star ratings in Global NCAP crash tests. The Carens Clavis includes six airbags even in base variants, while the Ertiga offers dual airbags and ISOFIX mounts. For buyers prioritizing safety, the Carens Clavis has a slight advantage.
Ownership Costs and Reliability
Maruti Ertiga’s service costs are significantly lower, averaging ₹5,192 annually. Its widespread service network and proven reliability make it a hassle-free choice. Kia’s service costs are higher, and availability of parts may vary regionally.
Verdict: Which MPV Should You Buy?
If your budget is strictly capped at ₹15 lakh and you need a reliable, fuel-efficient, and spacious 7-seater, the Maruti Ertiga is the clear winner. It builds on its predecessor’s strengths with smoother performance and better comfort.
If you’re willing to stretch your budget or prioritize premium features and cabin experience, the Kia Carens Clavis offers a more sophisticated package—but only in higher variants that exceed the ₹15 lakh mark.
Final Recommendation:
Choose the Maruti Ertiga for value, efficiency, and practicality. Opt for the Kia Carens Clavis only if you can afford the turbo-auto variant and want a more luxurious MPV experience.
Sources: Autocar India, CarDekho, CarWale, MSN India
Advertisement
Advertisement
