Image Source: Economic Times
Debate Erupts Around Cost-Effectiveness of Celebrity-Driven Social Media Marketing for Ola Electric
Deepika Padukone’s Instagram reel reportedly garnered a staggering 1.9 billion views for Ola Electric’s campaign, making it one of the most viewed celebrity endorsements on social media. However, Nitin Chandil, former Marketing Head at Ola Electric, publicly questioned the effectiveness of this virality, claiming that a significant portion of these views were artificially boosted through paid promotion rather than organic engagement.
Key Highlights and Criticism from Former Ola Electric Executive
The Instagram reel achieved a headline figure of 1.9 billion views, touted as a massive success for the brand’s digital marketing efforts.
Chandil highlighted a discrepancy between the view count and actual engagement, noting only 1.3 million likes from 1.9 billion views, equating to a mere 0.07% engagement rate.
He compared this to Deepika Padukone’s typical reels, which receive roughly 5 million views with a 5% engagement rate, suggesting that this campaign’s low engagement indicates heavy paid boosting rather than genuine audience interest.
Chandil estimated that the real organic views could be as low as 10 million, implying that almost 1.89 billion views might have been "bought" or artificially generated.
Based on these assertions, he questioned the campaign’s value for money, estimating that approximately Rs 33 crore spent on this social media boost may have been wasted.
Understanding the Marketing Dynamics and Paid Campaigns
Paid promotional campaigns on social media platforms like Instagram involve paying to amplify content impressions beyond organic reach, often resulting in inflated view numbers without corresponding user interaction. Although paid ads increase visibility, they do not guarantee genuine user engagement or conversions, often leading marketing experts to scrutinize the return on investment (ROI) and real impact.
In this context, Chandil’s critique stresses the distinction between vanity metrics (total views) and meaningful metrics (likes, shares, comments, and conversions). His insights warn brands against relying solely on massive viewership numbers without considering the quality and authenticity of audience engagement.
Industry Experts’ Take on Measuring Social Media Campaign Success
Engagement rates (likes, comments, shares) are considered a better indicator of campaign success than raw view counts.
Authentic organic reach fosters greater brand loyalty and conversion, while paid boosts may inflate numbers but deliver limited substantive benefits.
A low engagement rate in high-visibility campaigns can signal inefficiencies, misaligned targeting, or audience disinterest.
Strategic spending on social media should balance reach with meaningful interaction to maximize impact.
Implications for Ola Electric and Celebrity Endorsement Strategies
While celebrity endorsements like Deepika Padukone’s generate high attention instantly, recent controversies and product-related complaints have put Ola Electric under regulatory and consumer scrutiny. The marketing investment’s effectiveness is being questioned amid:
Allegations of consumer rights violations against Ola Electric.
Government investigations regarding warranty and service delays.
Declining organic consumer confidence linked to product and service issues.
Public spats and leadership controversies affecting brand reputation.
These challenges intensify the scrutiny on marketing spends and campaign outcomes, with former insiders like Chandil providing critical perspectives.
Conclusion: Balancing Reach with Real Impact in Influencer Campaigns
The discussion ignited by Nitin Chandil highlights emerging concerns in the digital marketing realm about distinguishing true audience engagement from inflated metrics driven by paid boosts. For brands like Ola Electric, whose reputation is simultaneously building and facing challenges, ensuring marketing spends translate into genuine consumer connection and trust is paramount.
This case exemplifies the need for transparent, data-driven evaluations of digital campaigns beyond view counts, focusing on authentic engagement, conversion efficiency, and long-term brand health.
Sources: Economic Times, Times of India
Advertisement
Advertisement
