US Vice President JD Vance ignited controversy on July 24 with a sharp critique of Microsoft’s hiring practices, accusing the tech giant of laying off 9,000 American workers while continuing to file thousands of H-1B visa applications. His remarks have triggered a wave of responses from Indian professionals and immigration advocates.
Notable points of Vance's statements
Vance challenged the rationale behind mass sacking and subsequent foreign recruitment, referring to it as a "bullsh*t story
He argued that companies should not blame talent shortages after dismissing local workers
The remarks were delivered during a bipartisan Hill and Valley Forum gathering, which was a change of tone from White House on employment-based immigration
Microsoft's layoffs and visa work
Microsoft has fired about 16,000 employees globally in 2025, 9,000 of whom were in July
Even after cutting back, the company filed over 9,000 H-1B petitions in the previous fiscal year
Social media accounts say there have been over 6,000 new app submissions since October, though not independently verified
Indian-American response and complexity
Critics charge Vance was ignoring the fact that most laid-off employees were H-1B holders themselves, with 60-day expulsion deadlines.
Technology investors assert that Microsoft gave extended visas to long-term employees stuck in green card backlogs, not new employees
The backlash is towards the complexities of visa renewals versus fresh recruitment
Political consequences
The H-1B debate is splitting Republicans, with populists being against it and pro-business elements coming to its defense
Vance's remarks may foreshadow more intense examination of tech hiring and visa reporting
Sources: Newsweek, Times of India, Financial Express, YourNews, VisaVerge, Economic Times, MSN India