Image Source: Times of India
A viral LinkedIn discussion contrasting the middle class of the 1970s with that of 2025 has set the generations alight with raging comments. The discussion took a fresh turn when 80-year-old retired IAS officer Shailaja Chandra, popularly known as 'Nani,' offered her first-hand insight, unapologetically stating that "the 2025s look better" despite the travails of the new era.
Key Highlights:
The Discussion: Entrepreneur Himanshu Kalra's viral post compared the "safe, linear" middle-class path of the 1970s (college, job, marriage, family) with the current "ferocious rat race" of education loans, outdated skills, rampant inflation, and non-stop upskilling. Kalra bemoaned the fact that both spouses now toil merely to keep their heads above water, usually at the expense of mental well-being.
Nani's View: Sh.ailaja Chandra refuted the gloomy picture, remembering that the 1970s, though austere, were "very restrictive." Most families lived frugally, sharing houses, where foreign holidays and dining out were periodic luxuries. Having or even leasing a well-situated house was a dream, and single-income families guarded every rupee vigilantly.
Why 2025 Is Better: Chandra emphasized the comfort and freedom of contemporary living—double incomes, cyber convenience, online shopping, net banking, and the ease of paying for children's pursuits. She emphasized that holidays, air travel, and gymnasium facilities are now accessible to the majority. Urban life is secure, and mobility in jobs enables professionals to reskill and boost their market value.
Generational Responses: The discussion brought out the varying responses. There were a few who concurred with Kalra regarding greater stress, inflation, and psychiatric issues, but others felt as optimistic as Chandra regarding greater opportunities, comfort, and empowerment in the information age. Nani's Cheeky Sign-Off: Chandra cautioned the young generation against assuming that the experience of their elders could be taken lightly: "Please think before you start arguing with me. Nanis and Dadis do have eyes, ears and a brain!"
"Change is rarely linear," Chandra concluded, requesting understanding and context as India's middle class negotiates a changing world.
Source: Business Today, Economic Times, NDTV
Advertisement
Advertisement
